IndustryPace
Ad industry commentary from Pesach Lattin. Since 2010.

From ADOTATEveryone Bought the AI Story. Season 10 Asks Where the Return Went.

OpenAI Called AI Ads a "Last Resort." The Last Resort Now Has a Self-Serve Ads Manager.

By ,

Start with the chatbot. In 2024 Sam Altman called AI advertising "uniquely unsettling" and a "last resort." On Feb. 9, 2026, OpenAI began testing ads in ChatGPT for Free and Go users in the U.S. Two years after the last resort, there is a self-serve ads manager. ADOTAT does not call that a scandal. It calls it what happens when a product needs a line going up. OpenAI says ads are matched to the topic, not the person, and that ads do not influence answers. ADOTAT's point: verify it, do not applaud the press release.

Then the agents. An IAB study of 205 U.S. buyers found about two thirds plan to lean harder into agentic buying this year. The IAB Tech Lab's own CEO, Anthony Katsur, said the talk had reached "a fevered pitch." Forrester calls 2026 a year of reckoning, and one widely cited forecast has more than 40% of agentic AI projects canceled by the end of 2027. ADOTAT's read: agents are good at the admin that eats a buyer's week, pacing and reports and reconciling. They will not tell you the metric is wrong. "The agent did it" is not accountability. It is an alibi.

Then the money nobody puts on a slide. The ANA's K2 work found cash rebates to media agencies were pervasive in its sample, with the programmatic trading desk singled out as a vehicle for opacity. Jared Belsky of Acadia told the show his agency took one vendor rebate and handed it back to clients pro rata. And on attention, WPP Media's own analytics lead, Premjeet Sodhi, wrote in June that the metric "arrived too late" and never won real commitment from clients. When the largest media buyer writes the obituary, believe it.

Why it matters: almost every Season 10 guest sells the cure for the problem they describe, and ADOTAT says so. The fix is not fewer vendors on mic. It is the same four questions every time: what did the client get, who else got paid, what has to be true for the claim to hold, and who answers if it does not. Ask every partner who owns frequency, and ask to see the cap. The ad industry is very good at selling answers. The receipts are the part it keeps leaving in the car.

The full story is at ADOTAT

Expanded from ADOTAT's Nov. 16 Season 10 issue, an ADOTAT+ post that is partly behind a paywall. Per ADOTAT, it draws on transcripts of all nine Season 10 episodes, with quotes being checked against the audio, and on the IAB 2026 Outlook study, Digiday, Dstillery, JWX, Forrester, WPP Media, the ANA and its K2 Intelligence work, the 4A's, Dentsu and trade coverage of OpenAI's ad rollout. The agentic cancellation figure and the Truist ad revenue estimate are projections, not results. The 33Across attention survey cited in the original is sponsored. ADOTAT says the named companies had not yet been given a right of reply. Belsky did not name the vendor whose rebate Acadia returned. Disclosures carried from the original: Troutman Amin sponsors The ADOTAT Show; Pesach Lattin has spent about two decades in and around the businesses these guests run, and has competed with many of them, sold to some and written about most; the original issue carried an ad for Incremental. ADOTAT is reader-supported, with no paid placement in editorial.