Pace Notes
Monday, November 16, 2026The ad business, read one turn ahead.
Four items to open the week. Stagwell hired a brand chief to tell its story, and ADOTAT checks the story against Freestar. Season 10 of The ADOTAT Show asks where the AI return went. A former FreeWheel ops chief gives ad tech fifteen years. The outside item is Amazon quietly moving where agencies put their fees. The Pick is Stagwell.
From ADOTATStagwell Just Hired Kate Richling to Explain Itself. Its Biggest Deal Still Needs Explaining.
Stagwell Calls Itself a Media Disruptor. It Buys Ads and Now Owns a Seller, Too.Pick
By Pesach Lattin,
On Nov. 6 Stagwell Media named Kate Richling its Chief Brand and Communications Officer, reporting to CEO Liz Rutgersson. The release calls Stagwell the "market's primary media disruptor" and says agency rhetoric and marketing are now "increasingly indistinguishable." Richling's own line is that she wants to align Stagwell Media's internal culture with its external narrative. ADOTAT went looking for the gap between her reputation and her record and did not find one. The gap is in the release.
Her record is real. She spent nine years at Monks, the S4 Capital shop once called MediaMonks, joining at 800 employees and leaving it at 9,000. As global CMO she ran PR, marketing and internal communications with a team of about 30, and she fired the outside PR agencies to bring the work in house. A 2023 Ragan profile credited her with helping fold more than a dozen companies under one name. She knows how to sell a story. That is exactly why the story matters.
Here is the story she inherits. Stagwell closed its purchase of Freestar, the Scottsdale publisher monetization company, on Oct. 23: $30 million in stock and $20 million in cash, plus up to $60 million more tied to earnings targets nobody has published. Stagwell sells it as "a more streamlined supply path." Mark Penn told analysts clients would get "special access and special kinds of media treatments" across Freestar's thousands of open web sites. Stagwell's owned media chief says it bought the technology and client relationships, not the publishers. Freestar's publishers are the sellers. Stagwell's media business is a buyer. Now one company sits on both sides of the trade.
Streamlined for whom is the only question that matters, and Stagwell has not answered it. No post-deal numbers on what publishers get paid, what data moves, or who wins the placements that "special access" implies. No disclosure of the earnout targets. That is Richling's first real assignment, and it is not a branding problem. A narrative only lines up with a culture when it survives a reporter reading the 10-Q. Publishers in the Freestar network should ask now, in writing, whether their rates change when the buyer owns the pipe.
- Stagwell Says Publishers Come First. Its Freestar Deal Now Feeds Principal Media.
- Everyone Bought the AI Story. Season 10 Asks Where the Return Went.
- The Field Kit: Affle Owns Discover-Tech's Name. Perion's CEO Says Affle Lets Brands Keep Theirs.
- Affiliate Marketing's Dirty Little Secret (IndustryPace, 2010)
Expanded from ADOTAT's Nov. 16 profile, which drew Richling's background from Stagwell's Nov. 6 release, a 2023 interview with The Goods, a 2023 Ragan awards profile, her LinkedIn profile and conference bios, and the Freestar figures from Stagwell's SEC 10-Q and its Oct. 26 announcement. The Penn quotes come from third-party transcripts of Stagwell's Q3 call and, per ADOTAT, were still being checked against the official record. Richling was not interviewed, and her Monks tenure rests on company releases and her own published remarks. Nothing here suggests wrongdoing by Richling; the open questions are about the Freestar deal terms Stagwell has not disclosed. The reading that one company now sits on both sides of the trade is ADOTAT's and IndustryPace's interpretation. Disclosure carried from the original: ADOTAT has interviewed Freestar before. ADOTAT is reader-supported, with no paid placement in editorial. Stagwell is a public company; this is commentary, not investment advice.
From ADOTATEveryone Bought the AI Story. Season 10 Asks Where the Return Went.
OpenAI Called AI Ads a "Last Resort." The Last Resort Now Has a Self-Serve Ads Manager.
By Pesach Lattin,
Start with the chatbot. In 2024 Sam Altman called AI advertising "uniquely unsettling" and a "last resort." On Feb. 9, 2026, OpenAI began testing ads in ChatGPT for Free and Go users in the U.S. Two years after the last resort, there is a self-serve ads manager. ADOTAT does not call that a scandal. It calls it what happens when a product needs a line going up. OpenAI says ads are matched to the topic, not the person, and that ads do not influence answers. ADOTAT's point: verify it, do not applaud the press release.
Then the agents. An IAB study of 205 U.S. buyers found about two thirds plan to lean harder into agentic buying this year. The IAB Tech Lab's own CEO, Anthony Katsur, said the talk had reached "a fevered pitch." Forrester calls 2026 a year of reckoning, and one widely cited forecast has more than 40% of agentic AI projects canceled by the end of 2027. ADOTAT's read: agents are good at the admin that eats a buyer's week, pacing and reports and reconciling. They will not tell you the metric is wrong. "The agent did it" is not accountability. It is an alibi.
Then the money nobody puts on a slide. The ANA's K2 work found cash rebates to media agencies were pervasive in its sample, with the programmatic trading desk singled out as a vehicle for opacity. Jared Belsky of Acadia told the show his agency took one vendor rebate and handed it back to clients pro rata. And on attention, WPP Media's own analytics lead, Premjeet Sodhi, wrote in June that the metric "arrived too late" and never won real commitment from clients. When the largest media buyer writes the obituary, believe it.
Why it matters: almost every Season 10 guest sells the cure for the problem they describe, and ADOTAT says so. The fix is not fewer vendors on mic. It is the same four questions every time: what did the client get, who else got paid, what has to be true for the claim to hold, and who answers if it does not. Ask every partner who owns frequency, and ask to see the cap. The ad industry is very good at selling answers. The receipts are the part it keeps leaving in the car.
- OpenAI and Meta Call It Enhancement. You're Liable for Ads You Never Read.
- Ricardo Belmar Says Nobody Hates Ads. He Clicks the Free Link.
- Matthew Wolff Simon Ran Global Ops at Comcast's FreeWheel. He Gives Ad Tech 15 More Years.
- Wire & File: Netflix Promised "Formidable." Its Ad Sales Chief Is Expected to Leave.
- Issues in Advertising Fraud: What Is Fraud? (IndustryPace, 2010)
Expanded from ADOTAT's Nov. 16 Season 10 issue, an ADOTAT+ post that is partly behind a paywall. Per ADOTAT, it draws on transcripts of all nine Season 10 episodes, with quotes being checked against the audio, and on the IAB 2026 Outlook study, Digiday, Dstillery, JWX, Forrester, WPP Media, the ANA and its K2 Intelligence work, the 4A's, Dentsu and trade coverage of OpenAI's ad rollout. The agentic cancellation figure and the Truist ad revenue estimate are projections, not results. The 33Across attention survey cited in the original is sponsored. ADOTAT says the named companies had not yet been given a right of reply. Belsky did not name the vendor whose rebate Acadia returned. Disclosures carried from the original: Troutman Amin sponsors The ADOTAT Show; Pesach Lattin has spent about two decades in and around the businesses these guests run, and has competed with many of them, sold to some and written about most; the original issue carried an ad for Incremental. ADOTAT is reader-supported, with no paid placement in editorial.
From ADOTATMatthew Wolff Simon Ran Global Ops at Comcast's FreeWheel. He Gives Ad Tech 15 More Years.
Ad Tech Sells Itself as the Future. FreeWheel's Former Ops Chief Gives It 15 Years.
By Pesach Lattin,
Matthew Wolff Simon ran global operations at Comcast's FreeWheel, where he built a team he puts at 250 people inside the Comcast India Engineering Center. On The ADOTAT Show he said the sentence no pitch deck will print: "Ad tech is an intermediary stage." His math is the Copernican principle. If ad tech is about fifteen years old, you are probably in the middle of it, so give it about fifteen more. He is now a partner at Xool Media & Tech, an ad tech company. The man thinks the house is temporary, and he just bought into the neighborhood.
The mechanism is the agent. Your personal AI reads your fridge, your bank account and your Amazon history, decides what you need, gets a human to say yes, and buys straight from the retailer. The goal of ad tech, he says, was always to unite a buyer with the product. Cut that middle out and the plumbing goes with it. His second claim is blunter: "Ad serving is middleware." In his words, "It's IT for IT," closer to fintech and SaaS than to Madison Avenue, and the industry hurt itself by hiring on ad tech credentials instead of software skill.
ADOTAT pushes back where it should. Every channel that promised to kill ads ended up carrying them. Search became the biggest ad business ever built. Streaming promised no commercials and now the ad tier is where the margin lives. Retail media networks already sell visibility to AI. The agent is not the end of advertising. The agent is the new shelf. And ad tech is not generic SaaS: a payments company fights fraud, but most software companies have never had a bot ask for an invoice. Hire from outside, ADOTAT says, but make sure the hires know some of what they measure is lying to them.
Why a buyer should care: his frame turns into four questions for the next vendor. Who is the product actually for? What happens when the middle step disappears? Who checks the traffic? What did you hire for? FreeWheel's analytics service holds MRC accreditation, a reminder that independent checks exist and are often skipped. ADOTAT agrees with him on the part the industry keeps forgetting: the tech gets rebuilt every decade. The people who run it are the only part that compounds.
Expanded from ADOTAT's Nov. 16 issue, based on Pesach Lattin's ADOTAT Show interview with Matthew Wolff Simon, recorded June 22, 2026, while he was still at FreeWheel; quotes were lightly edited from the recording. His current title was confirmed with him by email, per ADOTAT. The 250-person team and the fifteen-year estimate are his own figures; ADOTAT notes that counting from the first ad servers in 1996 would make ad tech closer to thirty years old. The MRC point refers to a September 2024 accreditation letter for FreeWheel's analytics platform, and ADOTAT found no evidence of Wolff Simon's personal role in that work. ADOTAT corrected an on-air title error: he was fractional COO, not CEO, of the start-up mAIself. Disclosures carried from the original: The ADOTAT Show is sponsored by Troutman Amin LLP and Incremental, which have no say over guests, questions or edits; the original post also carried a paid ad for a preferred stock, which is advertising, not editorial; ADOTAT uses AI tools, including Anthropic's Claude, in its production. ADOTAT is reader-supported, with no paid placement in editorial.
ElsewherePPC Land: Amazon's $78bn ad machine now sets the defaults agencies buy inside
Amazon Says It Doesn't Bill Agency Fees. It Now Decides Where Agencies Put Them.
By Pesach Lattin,
PPC Land's Luis Rijo published a long Nov. 14 read on a quiet shift: Amazon is moving from selling ad inventory to setting the defaults agencies build and bill campaigns inside. The scale is the reason it matters. By PPC Land's count, Amazon's ad revenue ran about $78 billion for the twelve months to Sept. 30. At unBoxed on Sept. 29, Amazon renamed its DSP DVA and folded it into its Ads Agent. One agency CEO's summary: "DSP is no longer DSP."
Now the fee change. A Support Center page dated Nov. 11 says the per-campaign agency fee setting can be used until Jan. 31, 2027 and is gone by the end of March. Fees for display, video and audio move to manager accounts, with five ways to calculate them. The page states Amazon doesn't bill agency fees. True. It also does not say whether the new fee setup applies to DVA+, the automated mode, or to its Full-Funnel Campaigns. PPC Land even found Amazon's own formula landing on a different number than a sentence on the same page. Amazon does not bill the fee. It just owns the form you put it on.
The defaults keep stacking. In DVA+ the automated build route is preselected. Since July 22, automatic deal selection has been the default for new Brand+ streaming TV prospecting lines. From Jan. 1, 2027, Amazon will count only on-screen display impressions, and expects far fewer of them, which means a higher price per impression on the same spend. Meanwhile the FTC and 22 states have alleged about $20 billion in hidden surcharges through a "soft reserve" price, which Amazon disputes, saying no advertiser pays more than their bid. Whoever writes the default writes the economics.
This is the thread ADOTAT keeps pulling. Netflix opened four DSP pipes, Amazon's among them, and watched its prices fall. Stagwell bought Freestar and now sits on both sides of the trade. Season 10 asks who earned what from your spend that you never saw. PPC Land cites an ANA survey in which 90% of marketers doubted their agency's recommendations served them. The fee did not disappear. It moved to a screen Amazon designed. Agencies and clients should read the new manager account terms before January, not after.
- Netflix Promised Buyers "Formidable." Its Ad Chiefs Keep Leaving.
- Stagwell Just Hired Kate Richling to Explain Itself. Its Biggest Deal Still Needs Explaining.
- Everyone Bought the AI Story. Season 10 Asks Where the Return Went.
- Stagwell Says Publishers Come First. Its Freestar Deal Now Feeds Principal Media.
- Who Can You Trust? Interactive Advertising Is Dangerous (IndustryPace, 2010)
Commentary on Luis Rijo's Nov. 14 analysis at PPC Land, which draws on Amazon Support Center pages, Amazon's earnings releases and executive statements, an ANA survey of 114 marketers, the FTC complaint and earlier trade reporting. The article is very long, and its closing section was not fully read for this item. The $78 billion trailing figure is PPC Land's count from Amazon's reported results; Amazon does not disclose advertising profit. The note that Amazon's fee formula conflicts with its own page is PPC Land's arithmetic. The FTC case is allegations only, and Amazon disputes them. The "DSP is no longer DSP" line is from Destaney Wishon, CEO of btr media, as quoted by PPC Land. The ADOTAT figures in the last paragraph come from the linked ADOTAT reports. Amazon, Netflix and Stagwell are public companies; this is commentary, not investment advice.